Article

How to audit payroll for overtime before you run it

Published · Sources checked

Overtime mistakes usually start in the time records, not in the payroll system. A missed punch, a workweek that starts on the wrong day, or a second job at a different rate can all change the overtime number. Checking the timecards before payroll runs is the cheapest point to catch them.

This guide walks through a practical overtime review using the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) as the baseline, then the state rules that most often change the answer.

1. Confirm the workweek

Under the FLSA, overtime is figured one workweek at a time. A workweek is "a fixed and regularly recurring period of 168 hours — seven consecutive 24-hour periods." It doesn't have to match the calendar week, but it has to stay fixed, and hours can't be averaged across two or more weeks. (WHD Fact Sheet #23; 29 CFR 778.104)

Check: does your time-clock export start the week on the same day and hour your payroll setup uses? A biweekly pay period is two separate workweeks, each with its own 40-hour line.

2. Total the hours actually worked in each workweek

Covered, non-exempt employees get at least 1.5× their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. (29 U.S.C. §207)

Look for the things that quietly change the total:

  • Missing or open punches. A shift with no clock-out can't be totaled correctly.
  • Short breaks recorded as unpaid. Federal rules treat short rest breaks (usually 5 to 20 minutes) as paid work time; only bona fide meal periods, usually 30 minutes or more with the employee fully relieved of duty, are not work time. (29 CFR 785.18; 29 CFR 785.19)
  • Rounding. Rounding to the nearest 5, 6 or 15 minutes is accepted only if, over time, it doesn't result in employees being undercompensated. (29 CFR 785.48)

3. Use the regular rate, not just the base rate

The overtime premium is based on the regular rate, which "includes all remuneration for employment except certain payments excluded by the Act itself." Non-discretionary bonuses are a common example of pay that belongs in it. When someone works two jobs at different rates in one week, the regular rate is generally the weighted average. (WHD Fact Sheet #23)

Check: flag anyone with a bonus, shift differential or two pay rates in a week with overtime, and confirm how payroll computes their regular rate.

4. Apply your state's daily rules

The FLSA has no daily overtime rule, but some states do. For example:

  • California: 1.5× over 8 hours in a workday and 2× over 12, plus 7th-consecutive-day rules. (Labor Code §510)
  • Alaska: 1.5× over 8 hours a day as well as over 40 a week, for employers with four or more employees. (AS 23.10.060)
  • Colorado: 1.5× over 40 a week, over 12 in a workday, or over 12 consecutive hours. (COMPS Order #40, Rule 4)
  • Nevada: daily overtime over 8 hours for employees paid less than 1.5× the minimum wage, with exceptions. (NRS 608.018)

5. Keep the records that support the numbers

Employers keep records of hours worked each day and each workweek, and the FLSA recordkeeping rules call for keeping time cards for two years and payroll records for three. (29 CFR 516.2; WHD Fact Sheet #21)

If you track time in a spreadsheet, the free timesheet template keeps daily and weekly hours in one place.

Doing this every pay period

A manual review works for a handful of employees. For more, PunchAudit reads the time-clock export you already have, checks weekly overtime for every state (and daily overtime and other state rules for California and Washington), and links each possible issue to the rule behind it. The weekly overtime calculator is free for checking a single week.

Informational only, not legal advice. Exemptions, agreements and local rules can change the answer; talk to an employment attorney or your state labor agency about your situation.